
What Cutting of Alfalfa Is Best for Horses?
On this page
No single cutting is best for every horse. Choose alfalfa by leaf, stem and lab results, then match its richness to the horse. Two of our third cutting alfalfas tested more than six points apart in protein, so the number alone will not tell you what is in the bale.
What cutting of alfalfa is best for horses depends on the horse and on when the hay was cut, so no single cutting wins every time. As a general rule, look for leafy, fine-stemmed alfalfa cut at the early bloom stage.
In many fields that points to second or third cutting. First cutting tends to carry more weeds and grass, and fourth and fifth cuttings tend to have more stems and fewer leaves. But the cutting number is only a rough guide, and our own lab panels show why.
How alfalfa changes from first cutting to later cuttings
Extension Horses says an alfalfa field generally gives five to eight cuttings a year when irrigated and four to five when not. It describes a typical season this way:
- First cutting: more weeds and grass.
- Second cutting: usually clean, with small stems.
- Third cutting: good hay.
- Fourth and fifth cuttings: begin to have more stems and fewer leaves.
That pattern is a starting point, not a rule. Succeed Equine calls maturity at harvest the single most important factor in the nutritional value of hay, and points out that a late second cutting could be lower in nutrition than an early first cutting.
What our alfalfa lab panels show
We carry four alfalfas with published lab panels. All four were tested by Equi-Analytical Laboratories:
- Ultra Premium Alfalfa, 1st cutting (sampled June 30, 2026): 25.1% crude protein as-fed, 10.9% NSC, RFV 249.
- Premium 2 Tie Alfalfa, cutting 2 (sampled August 17, 2026): 19.6% crude protein as-fed, 5.2% NSC, RFV 131.
- Premium Alfalfa, cutting 3 (sampled June 30, 2026): 24.8% crude protein as-fed, 10.8% NSC, RFV 223.
- Alfalfa Big Bales, cutting 3 (sampled September 24, 2026): 18.5% crude protein as-fed, 7.4% NSC, RFV 158.
NSC is non-structural carbohydrates, and RFV is relative feed value, where higher is richer.
Look at the two third cuttings. They carry the same cutting number and sit more than six points apart in crude protein. Meanwhile, our first cutting and our richer third cutting are within half a point of each other. Our second cutting lands between our two third cuttings. These are four tests of four lots, so they do not prove a rule about cuttings. They do show why you should read the panel instead of the label.
We test the field, not each bale. We sample bales from across the stack and combine the cores into one composite for the lab, and we pull a new test whenever the source or the cutting changes.
Is 3rd cutting alfalfa good for horses?
Yes, third cutting can be very good hay. Our Premium Alfalfa is a third cutting, and one customer review on our site says the 3-string 3rd cut alfalfa is wonderful for two older horses.
The catch is that a later cutting is not automatically a richer one, as our Alfalfa Big Bales panel shows. Those lower numbers are not a flaw. They can suit horses that do not need the richest hay.
Is first cutting alfalfa good for horses?
It can be. First cutting's weedy reputation comes from timing and field conditions, and an early first cutting can test very well. Our Ultra Premium Alfalfa is a first cutting with our highest crude protein and RFV of the four panels above.
Hay that rich is not right for every horse, so feed it in measured amounts and ask your vet if you are unsure.
Which cutting of alfalfa is best for your horse?
Start with the horse, then find the bale that fits:
- Hard keepers and horses in training: Succeed notes that alfalfa's higher protein and acid buffering effects make it a good option for horses in training.
- Easy keepers: they may do better on a stemmier, lower-nutrition hay than on rich alfalfa. Our Timothy 2nd Cut (sampled September 24, 2026) tested at 13.4% crude protein as-fed, 9.2% NSC and RFV 103.
- Horses used to alfalfa that need less of it: our Timothy Alfalfa Mix puts both in one 3-string bale.
- Metabolic or insulin resistant horses: ask your vet what NSC level your horse needs before choosing any hay.
How to judge an alfalfa bale, whatever the cutting
Look for a high leaf-to-stem ratio. Good hay is bright, fine-stemmed, leafy and clean smelling, while bad hay is brown or faded, coarse, and dusty or musty. Our guide on what bad hay looks like goes further.
If you want to go deeper, understanding hay cuttings covers cuttings across all hay types, and does alfalfa make horses hot deals with the most common alfalfa worry.
If a bale from us is moldy or dusty, bring it back and we will exchange it. Before you switch feed, ask to see the current lab results, which we keep on file at our Williston store on US Hwy 27. You can also call us at (352) 528-1255.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between 2nd and 3rd cutting alfalfa?
The two are often close, and maturity at harvest can separate them more than the number does. Second cutting is usually clean with small stems, and third cutting is also good hay. Our Premium 2 Tie Alfalfa is a second cutting. Compare leaf, stem and a lab panel before you choose between them.
Is first cutting alfalfa too rich for horses?
It depends on how early it was cut and which horse eats it. Our Ultra Premium Alfalfa, a first cutting, tested at 25.1% crude protein as-fed. For an easy keeper or a horse on a vet plan, that may be more than it needs.
What cutting of hay is best for an easy keeper?
Many easy keepers do better on a stemmier, lower-nutrition hay than on rich alfalfa. Check the current lab panel and your vet's target before you switch.
Why do horses leave the stems of alfalfa hay?
Coarse stems are less palatable, so horses tend to pick out the leaves and leave the rest. A bale with small stems and lots of leaf means less waste.
From the Williston yard
Questions about the right hay for your horse?
Call Hailey at the Williston store, or browse the catalog and we will get a load on the truck. Hay delivery runs across North Central Florida.